Sunday, September 7, 2008

September 12th and Procedural Rhetoric

I just played September 12th, for about 20 minutes, maybe even 30. It is a pretty straight forward, easy to play game. As I played, I was keeping in mind the idea of procedural rhetoric and how that influenced/affected the way the game was played.
Ian Bogost defines procedural rhetoric as "the practice of authoring arguments through process." (p. 29) I would argue that, in fact, this game does have a process of how to play and is a form of procedural rhetoric. While the game creators preface the game by saying it does not have a beginning or an end, when the player starts and stops playing the game serve as the beginning and end of their individual process. The creators also specify that you can not win-- it is a no win situation. Their argument, going to war following 9/11 is a no win situation, is the basis of the "authoring of arguments" per Bogost's definition of procedural rhetoric. (p. 29) So, we have fulfilled part of the requirement for procedural rhetoric in that we have an argument. The process part of the definition is fulfilled by the fact that the process of the game is to kill the terrorist and then, when you shoot a civilian whose mourners turn into terrorists, shoot/bomb them too. This cyclical process of killing a terrorist and then the mourners becoming terrorist, and having to kill them too relates to how it is not possible to win the game. There is no way you can only shoot the terrorist, you will almost always hit a civilian too. The process of killing the terrorist, waiting for your gun to recharge and then shorting again proves to be the second part of Bogost's definition being the process that is the argument. In our last class, someone said, and I am not sure who, "where there is meaning there is persuasion, and where there is persuasion, there is rhetoric." Here there is the persuasion that going to war against the terrorists is a no win situation using the persuasion through the procedures of the game, which means there must be rhetoric involved. This leads me to the conclusion that procedural rhetoric is an important aspect of September 12th.

No comments: