Sunday, December 7, 2008

The Storm is over... One last hurrah! (or should I say One last Blog!?!)

Wow.... This semester has taken me by storm! I knew entering into this class that I was in WAY over my head. I knew that it was on a topic that was about as every day to me as speaking Latin or Greek. I am not a game player nor do I really know much about rhetorics. I didn't know gaming theory or the lingo associated with the topic. I had never though that games could have some persuasive power. I thought of games as a way to pass time- entertainment that came and went like last seasons fashions. I would go so far as to say, to a certain extent, I thought of them as child's play.

I would be lying if I said that I didn't struggle in the class more or less everyday. Some days I felt like I was in a knock down, drag out war with the text. Some weeks I think it won. As I said before, I knew I was in way over my head and some days, I was sinking... like a rock. BUT now that it is said and done, now that the class is over, I honestly do not think I would change a thing about the semester. I have learned so much in this process both academically and personally.


I could go on and on about how much I have learned and every little detail, but those all seem trivial as to one major thing I figured out... something that it took most of the semester, weeks of blogging and blog-surfing, hours of discussions, even longer hours reading and re-reading... but I finally have a greater understanding of games and game studies. I finally see the educational power of games, the persuasive nature of games and the endless possibilities that exist in the world of games. These are things that I can take back to architecture and reframe them in an architectural context. The theories and ideas of game design seem very relevant and applicable to architecture.

I know a lot of the material we discussed that went flying over my head and I know I still have a lot to learn. However, I feel like I have learned so much as I came in with nothing. Game design and thought processes have forced me to rethink what I thought I knew about basic gaming as well as rethink how all of this is and can be related to architecture.

As I finish this class up, I am honestly happy I took the class even with the stress and fear it brought to my life on an almost daily basis. I would not trade the discussions, even the heated ones, for something I was more familiar with. This class forced me to step outside my comfort zone and my little world for something bigger. It stretched me to think and learn in ways I did not know possible. And I think that for it, I will be a better designer and architect.

Thursday, November 13, 2008

Cool video on Architecture, SL, and Machinama...

Found this kind of cool video on Architecture in Second Life and Machinima....




Wednesday, November 12, 2008

Video Games and Art- Part 1

At this point, I have read about 120 pages of the approx. 150 we were supposed to have ready for tonight.... but I am going to go ahead and post a blog post. I may add another once I have finished reading the last part of what I have to read or maybe just modify what I have. I might even just leave it as it is and wait and see how the discussion unfolds this evening in class.
First let me start by saying I was very interested the introduction, in most part, because of her discussion of video game art in the realm of art and art history. In undergrad I took many art history classes... enough to get a second minor that I never declared. Anyways, I found it interesting from an art history perspective where Mitchell and Clarke write "video game art is one of the most postmodern of art forms because it brings together such extremes of high culture (art) and low culture (the video game)." (p.9) Wow.... so true. It was not something I had every really thought of before, but definitely something that resonated with me when I saw it written here in our book. They go on to discuss how not only does video game art fall under postmodernism, but also pop art. Wow.

In Axel Stockburger's From Appropriation to Approximation, he adds to this idea of video game art in the greater realm of art history. Early on in the essay, he says "Johan Huizing... posited play and games at the roots of all cultures and clarified that they permeate various sectors of society such as art, philosophy, law and politics." (p. 25) He goes on to say that "every profane object that is transported into the museum at some point in time is thereby valorized and transformed into a work of art." (p.26) At that point, in the margin of my book, I wrote "The Fountain" which is a piece of art by Marcel Duchamp. (image to right is a replica of the original as the original was lost shortly after its completion in 1917- Image from: http://arthistorian.files.word%20press.com/2007/08/duchamp_%20fountain.jpg_) On the top of the next page, he actually talks about Marcel Duchamp. Ge says "Groys relates to Marcel Duchamp as one of the most important artist, who have directly addressed the process of transformation from non-art to art. The concept of the ready-made challenged the differentiation process itself and has thus also transformed the rules of art itself."(p.27) I never would have liked video games to art and it never would have crossed my mind, until now that is, that this new medium of video games as art is an equivalent movement of the ready-mades in early 20th century art. Finally... something I understand!!!


On page 28, Stockburger goes on to discuss Game On. He says it was "an interesting example for the shift of perception that has been taking place in the last decade." He goes on to talk about how Henry Jenkins and Kurt Squire "promote the notion of computer games as the "art of contested spaces" believing we "should consider viewing games as spatial art with its roots in architecture, landscape, painting, sculpture, gardening, or amusement park design." I can think of several examples that come to mind in relation to architecture, landscape, and amusement park design... below are a series of images relating to the games I thought of...

Amusement park design.... Roller coaster tycoon.....

The Sims 2.... both for architecture and landscape....

(from http://www.pimp-my-sims.com/)




From Google Images



Tuesday, November 4, 2008

This week's post- Part 1: Exercise (chp 10)

This week we were to read the last two chapter's of Bogost's book. So, I am going to do one post on Chapter 10 about Exercise and then will do a second post on the Purpose of Persuasion chapter.

Bogost opens the chapter talking about Dance, Dance Revolution (DDR). While I have never played DDR, I do have/play a newer version of an "exercise" game. I have a Wii Fit. It actually was my dad's father's day gift, but he has very kindly shared the Wii Fit with me, since the Wii lives at my house. Since I use the Wii Fit on a fairly regular basis, I was very interested to hear what Bogost had to say. On page 294, Bogost says "... I seek to understand their core rhetorics-- the ways that these games are authored to motivate their players to engage in physical activity." In Wii Fit, there are several ways the game designers have authored the game to keep you coming back. First, once you have created your Mii (your personal avatar in the world of Wii), you choose who your trainer will be- a man or a woman. Your personal trainer is always helpful and works to try to help you feel like you are making progress. If you do very well on your different exercises, your trainer is quick to tell you good job. If you falter, could be putting a foot down when doing a yoga move on the balance board or not keeping your balance centered on a balance exercise, your trainer will give you positive reinforcement about what you did wrong as well as how you can improve your performance. The program also reinforces the good behavior of doing exercise by giving you "coins" in the back for every minute you do exercise. The more you build up, the more exercises and activities open up for you to enjoy. It also opens up new stamps you can use on your Wii Fit calendar that shows which days you worked out on Wii Fit. I think it is fair to say these things the game does to make you feel good for working out are the "core rhetorics" that the game designers use to "motivate their players to engage in physical activity." For me... I guess you could say it worked. (with the added benefit that it is fun!)

Wednesday, October 15, 2008

Week 8- Discussion


First off, as I read through this section of Bogost's book, I was caught when he says "Advertising shifted from a minimalist, rationalistic strategy to a spectacular, emotional one." (p. 150) The first thing that came to mind, and maybe it is just my sappy side, but the first commercial/advertisement that came to my mind was the ASPCA commercial featuring Sarah McLachlan's song Angle. (I have included the commercial below for those who have not seen it.... it definitely is of the emotional type....)



(from youtube.com... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8EYocy_DN60)



Bogost goes on to discuss three different types of advertising- Demonstrative, illustrative, and associative. This section reminded me of some examples in the game The Sims 2. (I think the examples from The Sims 2 come from the fact that I am not a gamer and this is the only game I have ever really played) In recent years, The Sims 2 developers have added expansion packs and objects that are of a specific brand. For example, originally, the cars in The Sims 2 were generic. You could buy a van, a truck, and junk car, a sports car, or a hot rod but none were a specific brand or ever really resembled in body lines a specific brand of car. Then, Ford partnered with The Sims 2 where you could download new Fords including the Ford Focus, Fusion, Edge, Mustang, and Escape Hybrid (gotta get in with all those "green" people...), and all but the mustang can be modified to several different colors to suit your taste. While I am not totally sure what form of advertising this would be, it is advertising. It is clearly the goal of Ford that people will see their sims "buying" Fords which will make the consumer want to have the same car their sim has.

(The images below are all from The Sims 2 Web page) Another example from The Sims 2 is when they partnered with the store H&M to do a fashion based "stuff" pack- basically an expansion pack that just added objects and stuff your sims could buy or objects you can use to build new H&M stores in your sim's town. This would be another form of advertising. While the clothes you can buy are not exactly what you can but in H&M stores, the styles were the in looks when the expansion pack came out and resembled clothes you can buy in actual H&M stores.

(Above image from : http://thesims2.ea.com/about/sp5_index.php)
Bogost mentions in the chapter Licensing and Product Placement that "Procedural rhetoric takes advantage of this tendency to make claims about how things work in the world. In the domain of advert sing, video games, deploy procedural rhetoric when they simulate player-consumer interaction with products and services, rather than merely simulating advertising through the application of images into virtual environments." (Bogost, 173) This is where I would expect that The Sims 2 examples I mention above would fall. Players interact with the clothes and the cars and what not as opposed to there just being billboards of H&M stores in the sim's town, which would be just the application of images into a virtual environment.

Wednesday, October 8, 2008

Weekly Discussion- Week 7 or 8... I am not sure....

In the midst of the buzz of preparing for my review tomorrow for my Architecture studio, I decided to take a break from my model to read for RCID. I found the chapter, Digital Democracy, very interesting, in part because of my own experience in the election process. Growing up, my dad was a politician, so I have spent lots of time around both him during his election cycle as well as in more recent years helping with different campaigns. I was especially interested in Howard Dean's game.

In the middle of the section about the game, I stopped reading and started playing the game. Before getting to the section about the tactics of grassroots campaigning, I had already thought about how this was a way for people to see that they can easily help with any campaign. It does not matter whether it is a presidential campaign or a local mayor race, the tactics of getting flyers/pamphlets out, knocking on people's doors, and waving signs are used across the board. Very interesting that the game designer opted to express these activities in the virtual world of the game.

I also found several of the other games intriguing but also a bit strange such as the World Trade Center attack game and the JFK Reloaded. I was kind of disturbed that the games existed and that someone would want to design such games, but they were somewhat interesting. I especially thought it was interesting when Bogost began discussing JFK Reloaded and how no one to date had been able to recreate the assassination as it happened according to the report.

I don't really have any other intellectual thoughts at the moment... but I might add some more a little later.....

Wednesday, October 1, 2008

Game Design as Narrative Architecture... This week's discussion Part 1

Game Design as Narrative Architecture

As an architect, the title of this article caught my eye. It has something I recognize—ARCHITECTURE. Yay… something I know and understand. Something I can relate to and build upon.
That being said, the first thing that really caught my eye as I was reading through the article was on page 673 where Jenkins says “Narrative analysis need not be prescriptive… The goal should be to foster diversification of genres, aesthetics, and audiences, to open gamers to the broadest possible range of experiences.” Architecture is an experience. The word aesthetics and the idea of what aesthetics is and what it can mean and how it can affect the viewer. Architecture is obviously very connected to the aesthetic—how a building looks and appears- the beautiful and pleasing to the eye. So that connection was immediately made. Jenkins also talks about genres and audiences. While I would not say we specifically have genres and audiences, there are translations that I think can be made to architectural ideas and terms designers use regularly. An architectural genre can definitely be linked to the style and maybe even building type. A modernist building, for example the famous Bauhaus in Dessau, Germany, is a very different genre (in architecture it would be a different architectural style) than Frank Gehry’s Guggenheim in Bilbao, Spain (Expressionist). Unlike games whose audience is composed of gamers, our audience consists of the people who work, live, and spend any time in around a building. I say in and around a building because you don’t have to physically go into a building to be a part of the building or to experience the building. (example…. When you are walking down an urban street, you know a building is beside you. The building holds the street edge. When a building is missing or is recessed, the feeling as you go by it is different from the rest of the street—without turning your head or even specifically looking at it, you know that there is something different about how that area of the street feels. As Michael Frederick says “Suburban buildings are freestanding objects in space. Urban buildings are shapers of space. (Frederick, 7) Each member will interpret and appreciate each building differently. For example, the modernist building with clean lines and simplistic forms is very aesthetically pleasing to me but many (my father for example) prefer the more traditional architecture.
Later in the article, Jenkins says “Game designers don’t simply tell stories; they design worlds and sculpt spaces.” (p. 674) I would have to argue that is 100% true. It seems that for a game to have any sort of power to keep players playing and intrigued with the game, it has to have some sort of design to it in the form of a world in which to exist and spaces to interact in. This could be seen in the immense worlds of WoW and the “indoor” spaces that those game designers created in the stores, shops, homes, inns, etc. This, the “design of worlds and sculpt[ing] spaces” directly relates to architecture. The architectural term we use for spaces that are memorable both architecturally and experientially is Genius loci. Genius loci translated means Genius of Space. These are spaces that you remember both visually and how they made you feel.
On page 676, I think the quote from the Senior Designer for Walt Disney Imagineering hits the nail on the head. Senior Designer Don Carson said “The story element is infused into the physical space a guest walks or rides through. It is the physical space that does much of the work of conveying the story the designers are trying to tell…. Armed only with their own knowledge of the world and those visions collected from movies and books…” (Jenkins, 676) Architects tell stories all the time with buildings. They are different from the kinds of stories that are being told by gaming designers, but they are, none the less, stories and parallels—very much inter-related. You start a design project with an idea. That idea is translated into form and functions. In many ways, the program of an architectural design is the story that is being told through the designed building.
Finally, I got very excited when Jenkins discussed Kevin Lynch’s Image of the City. It is a book that I have read several times for different classes including my senior exit studio in undergrad and then just last year for a History and Theory of Urbanism class. While I found the passage Jenkins included very interesting, some of the specifics that Lynch discusses in depth are very applicable to game designs. Lynch’s five elements were very evident in WoW, whether or not the game designers meant to include them or not. Lynch says that there are 5 elements that are imperative to urban/city design and also critical to mental maps (and thus understanding and experiencing cities and urban environments. The five elements are: paths (streets, sidewalks, trails, etc. on which people travel), edges (perceived boundaries like shorelines, forests, etc), districts (relatively large sections of the city distinguished by some identity or character), nodes (intersections, points of convergence, focal points, intersections), and landmarks (places/buildings that are easily recognizable and act as reference points). Though I did not think about it while I was playing WoW, thinking back on it, they were very obvious. For example Paths. That one is very clear. In my previous post, I show a picture of my avatar with the path she is traveling in front of her. Edges could be the mountains you can’t get over or possibly even the rivers that distinguish one area of the WoW world to another area. Districts would be the different areas such as the different forests or castles and the town in the world I was playing in. Nodes would be the places where many paths come together and you could roll the cursor over the sign with the arrows on it to find your way. At those points paths came together and you have to choose which direction you were going to travel. Finally, landmarks in WoW included the Turret in the world I was in or different elements in the landscape such as hay bales or even a hill/mountain were landmarks that helped me reference where I was and where I needed to be going. Since I have a copy of the book, I will bring it to class for anyone interested in looking at it. As Jenkins said “game designers would do well to study Lynch’s book.” It would be a great tool for understanding city/urban design and how that can affect the way a game designer would design a town or city in a game.

More to come later on the other readings....



Also. the above images came from the following:


Saturday, September 27, 2008

A Frew Screen Shots of my time with WoW

The following are a few pictures of my time in WoW.... see the captions under each picture

This is my avatar.... on one of the paths while I was exploring.


My avatar under water... I thought it was cool that I could get a picture under the water. I also thought it was funny that the little breath bar comes up to remind me to make my avatar come to the surface for air. (espcially since it is a virtual world....)


Here is my avatar under water again. I was trying to get a good view of the mountain that I was trying to climb. I could not climb it because there was bad guys all around it trying to protect it.


Here is the same mountain and water fall above water.


This is my avatar in front of the gates to her castle.... I figured she needed a typical tourist picture.



Hahahaha! This picture is how I spent most of my time on WoW... as a GHOST!


This was my avatar right after I lead her ghost back to her corpse.


I included this picture because I like how the back ground is "pretty". Sort of. It is an attempt to be pretty, but, to me, it is not very realistic so I dont know if Pretty is really the correct word.


This is another "pretty" aspect of the game- the skys and sunsets... the sky turned pretty colors when the sun is setting in the game....



This is another view of the path before my avatar as I was exploring.














Tuesday, September 23, 2008

Week 5 Discussion

Ideological Frames......

First, Bogost begins the chapter by saying that "The 2004 U.S. presidential election renewed world citizen's recognition of an ideological polarization in U.S. politics." (Bogost, 99) The first thing that came to my mind was it happens every presidential election. Here we are 4 years later and we are seeing the same thing. It is interesting to read through what he says in the opening paragraph and then continues as he discusses Lakoff and Johnson in comparison to what we are seeing now in our society during this historical election season. Bogost goes on to say that "Lakoff and Johnson argue that our conceptual systems are fundamentally shaped by cultural constructions." (Bogost, 99) To me, that cannot even be argued. His examples of calling global warming “ climate change” and “war on terror as opposed to war in Iraq are two of many examples that come to mind of such types of wording to change the frame to which most Americans see the issue/idea. It seems pretty straightforward and true. He finishes out the section by saying “frames or contexts are not merely theoretical structures for intellectual navel-gazing; they are operational models that are actively influencing public policy. This seems to further that idea that how things are phrased affects and alters how people think of a specific topic.
He goes on to discuss political videogames and their impact. He talks about some political games use procedural rhetoric while others use written and visual rhetoric that are “peppered” through the traditional action game. As a child, I played SimEarth (probably is still in the box on the bookshelf in the playroom at my parent’s house). At the time I had no clue of its political aspect. It was a game I wanted, so I saved and bought it. As with most videogames I have ever played, I find them interesting for a little while and then it is on to the next one. However, now looking back on it, it was a political message that my child min did not understand. It makes me wonder if my parents (both VERY non-gamers) picked up on the political aspects of the game.
Finally, I want to mention where Bogost discusses the “tension between personal responsibility and social forces.” My question is it really an issue dealing with morality or is it just self-control which, by definition, are different. He says that “moral strength entails the courage to stand up to both internal and external evils, and it is fundamentally related to will.” (p. 114) While “will” is very much related to self-control, I am not sure where Moral comes into the picture. I don’t think self-indulgence is a moral issue—it, to me is possibly self-control, but not a moral issue, where Lakoff says that it falls into “the domain of the morally weak.”

WoW....or not so much....

World of Warcraft... where do I even begin....

The task given to us was to play to be a level 6 player. I have gotten to level 5.... 5 and half to be exact. I can’t seem to get over the hump to get to level 6. I have completed several quests, but all the quests now available to me (or at least that I can find), I die trying to complete them. I can’t kill the Boar or Kobold (sp?) before it kills me first. It’s the never ending circle-- go from Goldshire to the mine, try to kill the Kobold to get the candle, get killed by the Kobold, end up back in the cemetery in Goldshire, take my spirit/ghost back to the mine, accept my body back, regain my health, try to kill the kobold (for a candle of course to give to the apothecary guy), only to be killed and have this process start again. I think I have spent more time traveling back to my body after dying than actually fighting the kobold for the candle. This game was just not meant for me. (sorry to those that are offended and LOVE the game.... its just not for me.)
That being said, I have spent a great deal of time playing the game and trying to understand the game to advance. I have a bit of the achiever in me that Bartle discusses, so when at first I don't succeed, I try, try again. (Or in my case, if after the first 30 attempts I don't succeed, I will just keep trying.....) I want to "win" the game and complete the quests! In last week's class discussion, we talked about if WoW is designed for achievers. We basically said that it allows for all to find a niche as well as flexibility for all types of players. While I agree that, for the most part, that is true-- people, whether Achiever, Socializer, Killer, or Explorer, can succeed, it seems like it is geared most to achiever. I am part achiever, but mostly explorer. Maybe it is the architect/designer in me or maybe just my personality in general, but I wanted to go and find every nook and cranny in the game. I want to explore the mountains, the forests, the rivers, etc. I found it very hard to explore many areas because I was getting slashed by random bad guys in the game or crazy big spiders and other such "animals" that were to keep me from different areas. Sometimes I found ways around the killers, many times I would get killed and then have to start the cyclical process again. As for the achiever in me, it may be that with a little help from someone who knows more about the game, I would be more successful. Even if I knew how to use the money I have collected/earned to buy better armor or a better weapon, I would be more successful. I could not figure out how to do it. I would buy something and it would tell me I could not use it. I don’t understand the rules enough even after playing for probably 10+ hours. For me, that would lead me to believe that the procedural rhetoric of the game is lacking. If, as Bogost defines, procedural rhetoric is "the practice of authoring arguments through processes," then it would seem that the game would be designed in such a way that even a gaming newbie such as myself would be able to understand the process enough that some argument could be made. For me, the argument is losing strength when the process is so complex that I have lost total sight of any argument that may or may not be made.

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Week 4 Discussion- Part 2

The Digital Culture, Play, and Identity: A World of Warcraft reader was very helpful to someone like me who knows NOTHING about World of Warcraft (WoW). Espen Aarseth's chapter A Hollow World: World of Warcraft as Spatial Practice was a great opening for me. It set the stage and gave me an idea of what I can expect in the game. It also helped me understand the background to which the culture of WoW is set.

In World Creation and Lore: World of Warcraft as Rich Text, I began to get a better understanding of WoW as well as the background and, I guess you could call, historical context of the game. This chapter enabled a knowledge base that will aid in playing the game as well as understanding the game from a more academic standpoint.

The next chapter, Klastrup's What Makes World of Warcraft a World? A note on Death and Dying, I was able to get a better understanding of the WoW culture. This was furthered by the suggested websites that allow for another aspect of understanding. Ordinarily, I would not have thought about culture in a game, but it is becoming more evident to me that it is truly the case.

Finally, Quests in World of Warcraft: Deferral and Repetition- The actual examples of game play quests were helpful. By describing what players actually do, I am beginning to get a better understanding of WoW.

These all combine to give me a broad understanding of the game from the internal workings to what the player does to play the game, to how culture and the idea of place affect the gamer, all leading to the basis of a holistic view of the game both from the academic world as well as the player/gamer side.

Its all Greek to Me... Discussion Question- Week 4 part one

Its all Greek to me. I know for most you, most of what these authors discuss is not completely new to you and you have a pretty good grasp on the jargon and language of the field. To me, it is all Greek, or Latin, or what ever other foreign language sounds good to you. Coming into this from a completely different background, some things stick out to me that you would probably never notice. One example this week was while I was reading through Bartle's Hearts, Clubs, Diamonds, Spades: Players Who Suit MUDs. I quickly found that he never once says what MUDs means. I read the first page, nothing. I figured by the 2nd or 3rd page, I would find out. Again, Nothing. Luckily, I am a smart girl and went straight to my quick find source-- Wikipedia! Wikipedia defines MUD as:

"In computer gaming, a MUD (Multi-User Dungeon, Domain or Dimension) is a multi-player computer game that combines elements of role-playing games, hack and slash style computer games and social chat rooms. Typical MUDs are text-driven, where players read descriptions of rooms, objects, events, other characters, and computer-controlled creatures or non-player characters (NPCs) in a virtual world. Players interact with each other and the world by typing commands that resemble a natural language. It has been argued that modern game-like MMORPGs, such as World of Warcraft, and social virtual worlds such as Second Life can have their origins traced back to the original MUDs.[1] Traditional MUDs implement a fantasy world populated by fictional races and monsters, with players being able to choose from a number of classes in order to gain specific skills or powers. The object of this sort of game is to slay monsters, explore a fantasy world, complete quests, go on adventures, create a story by roleplaying, and advance the created character. Many MUDs were fashioned around the dice rolling rules of the Dungeons & Dragons series of games. Such fantasy settings for MUDs are common, while many others are set in a science fiction–based universe or themed on popular books, movies, animations, history, and so on. Not all MUDs are games; some, more typically those referred to as MOOs, are used in distance education or for virtual conferences. MUDs have attracted the interest of academic scholars from many fields, including communications, sociology, law, and synthetic economies." (From: Wikipedia)

Unfortunately, from there, I had to figure out what NPC's, MMROPGs, and MOOs are. Luckily, they are all linked to further articles where I am finally up to speed with all of the jargon of the article/field.

I just thought that was an interesting tid-bit, but I am certain for you all, it seems very odd that I don't know these things!

Tuesday, September 9, 2008

Week #3 Discussion Questions

The first part of the chapter discusses how first responders respond to catastrophes. Bogost begins by using a hypothetical bioterrorist event at UC Berkeley seen in the game BioChemFX. It really hit home with me when he asked "...whom do they save? the freshmen or the Noble laureates? The homeless or the convenience store clerks?" He went on to talk about Hurricane Katrina. I found how he went about disucssing the project very interesting. While the catastrophic damage occurred in a physical sense, "physical faults" as Bogost call them, but more importantly catastrophic events occurred on the social side of the storm. Bogost says he "no longer needed a hypothetical example of how the perceived value of specific human lives might lead to impasse in a crisis." (p. 67) In my History and Theory of Architecture and Health class, we discussed this same topic. From the standpoint of health and health care, obviously a very different aspect of the storm than Bogost is addressing, the US government, FEMA, local government, etc ultimately failed all, but specifically the poor residents of of New Orleans and other low-lying areas of the gulf coast. It was good to see that in recent events of Hurricane Gustav, many of the issues with refusal to help the poor and unable were fixed by helping them get out of town and out of harms way by evacuating them to other places. After discussing congress' report of Kartrina and the 9/11 commission report, Bogost goes on to say that "the solution to the next Katrina is assumed to be inside the real of current procedure. The government is just using those procedures inneffectively." (p. 69) I think the preparedness and pre-storm plan for Gustav prove just that fact, even though Gustav was not the storm they thought it might be.

Later in the chapter Bogost talks about the U.S. Army's America's Army: Operations game. Given we are at war, and have been for a long time, it made for a unique marketing method. From a gaming aspect, it seemed like it would give the player a fairly realistic experience of what the Army is like, but does have some short comings. The process of gaining skills and rank in a way that mimics its real life counter-part as well as the game's methods of punishing the player for things they do wrong is a form of procedural rhetoric. The game, which was designed to be used as a marketing tool to increase the number of people enlisting in the Army as well as to raise the level of respect by general members of the US, uses the processes of the game (learning rifle/shooting skills, completing specific tasks and missions, rules of behavior, etc) to author the argument that the Army is a good organization worth enlisting in and supporting, changing the opinion of many. The game is an "authorship of rules of behavior." (p. 29)

Finally, Bogost's discussion of political games provided a new side of the political process I had not considered before. Given that we are leading up to a historical election, no matter what what side wins-- it will be historical, the idea that games can simulate the election process is mind boggling to me. I had no idea such games as President Elect or The Doonesbury Election Game: Campaign '96 even existed. I wonder if there are games out about our current election and how they work. When Bogost says "all of the games follow a common procedural rhetoric: elections are won by electioneering, not politics," (p. 91) I have to tend to agree. One example that comes to mind is the pregnancy of conservative VP candidate Sarah Palin's daughter. The liberals are trying to use that as a electioneering negativity that she cant be a good VP because she has a unmarried, 17 year old daughter who is pregnant. Ultimately, that will have nothing to do with her as VP candidate. While I am not saying that she is qualified to be the VP or president and not saying that I am her supporter of her, but this is a recent example of electioneering that many are familiar with.

September 12th Revisited

Over the weekend I read the readings except for the last few pages, which turned out to be about the games we have been asked to play-- Kabul Kaboom, Madrid, and September 12. So, now that I have read the part where Ian Bogost talks about September 12, I want to go back and revisit September 12.
I like I mentioned in the previous post that the game has no beginning and no end, Bogost says "September 12 continues indefinitely; no goals or completion states are suggested or imposed." (p. 86) He goes on to talk about the process of the game where the villagers and terrorists move through the village, you destroy buildings by bombing them but they rebuilding themselves over time, and the villagers mourn their dead fellow villagers morph into terrorists. Bogost goes on to say "the tool the game provides for combating terrorism," which I mention above, "is revealed to be a sham-- using missiles to root out terrorists only destroys innocent lives." (p. 87) He even goes so far as to say "September 12 claims that this logic of counter terrorism is broken; no one is made any safer by following it, and in fact more innocent lives are lost." (p. 87) Maybe he is correct......

Sunday, September 7, 2008

September 12th and Procedural Rhetoric

I just played September 12th, for about 20 minutes, maybe even 30. It is a pretty straight forward, easy to play game. As I played, I was keeping in mind the idea of procedural rhetoric and how that influenced/affected the way the game was played.
Ian Bogost defines procedural rhetoric as "the practice of authoring arguments through process." (p. 29) I would argue that, in fact, this game does have a process of how to play and is a form of procedural rhetoric. While the game creators preface the game by saying it does not have a beginning or an end, when the player starts and stops playing the game serve as the beginning and end of their individual process. The creators also specify that you can not win-- it is a no win situation. Their argument, going to war following 9/11 is a no win situation, is the basis of the "authoring of arguments" per Bogost's definition of procedural rhetoric. (p. 29) So, we have fulfilled part of the requirement for procedural rhetoric in that we have an argument. The process part of the definition is fulfilled by the fact that the process of the game is to kill the terrorist and then, when you shoot a civilian whose mourners turn into terrorists, shoot/bomb them too. This cyclical process of killing a terrorist and then the mourners becoming terrorist, and having to kill them too relates to how it is not possible to win the game. There is no way you can only shoot the terrorist, you will almost always hit a civilian too. The process of killing the terrorist, waiting for your gun to recharge and then shorting again proves to be the second part of Bogost's definition being the process that is the argument. In our last class, someone said, and I am not sure who, "where there is meaning there is persuasion, and where there is persuasion, there is rhetoric." Here there is the persuasion that going to war against the terrorists is a no win situation using the persuasion through the procedures of the game, which means there must be rhetoric involved. This leads me to the conclusion that procedural rhetoric is an important aspect of September 12th.

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

Week #2 Discussion Questions

As someone who has no background in this, I do have a few basic questions, just to understand the background. First, on page 4, Bogost says "computer softwarre establishes rules of execution, tasks and actions that can and cannot be performed." For someone who is trying to get a very basic understanding of how computers and software work, does this mean that software is programmed to allow the player/user to certain things and not others. My nephew is a big Sims 2 player, so I have some understanding of that program, so I will use it here as my example. In the sims 2, players control people in the program but there are somethings that are not options for the player to chose the person in the game to do. Example- in the game adults can increase relationship levels to such that they can have sex, or in the game it is called woohoo, with another person in the game. However, teenagers, no matter how much they have built a relationship with another teenager, they can not have sex. Is this an example of that? Like I said before, this is all very new for me and I am trying to figure out how the software is programmed...

A similar question on how software is programmed came about on page 5 where Bogost talks about symbols. It says " computation is 'interpretable symbol manipulation' in which symbols 'are manipulated on the basis of rules operaing only on t he symbol's shapes...'" Is this similar to how math symbols such as the plus, minue, multiply and divide symbols along with parentheses and equal signs organize an equation into the correct order of operations? For example 1+ (2x3) would tell us that you multiply 2x3 first (because of the parentheses) and then add the 1 such that you get 7.


On a less basic note, the author spent a good deal of time talking about rhetoric beyond oratory. With my background being in architecture, the first thing that came to mind was architectural rhetoric. While this could fall into the realm of artistic rhetoric in many ways, I think it is its own distinct category. Merriam-Webster defines rhetoric as Main Entry:

rhet·o·ric
Pronunciation:
\ˈre-tə-rik\
Function:
noun
Etymology:
Middle English rethorik, from Anglo-French rethorique, from Latin rhetorica, from Greek rhētorikē, literally, art of oratory, from feminine of rhētorikos of an orator, from rhētōr orator, rhetorician, from eirein to say, speak — more at word
Date:
14th century
1: the art of speaking or writing effectively: as a: the study of principles and rules of composition formulated by critics of ancient times b: the study of writing or speaking as a means of communication or persuasion 2 a: skill in the effective use of speech b: a type or mode of language or speech; also : insincere or grandiloquent language3: verbal communication : discourse

Bogost says " rhetoric... also came to refer to effective expression, that is writing, speech, or art that both accomplishes the goals of the author and absorbs the reader or viewer." (pg. 19) With that said, Architectural rhetoric is an effective expression where the goals of the architect/designer are expressed to the person experiencing and seeing a building, space, or environment. Behind any good architecture and well-designed building or environment, there is an idea that is being expressed, that if expressed well, will be persuasive to the person who experiencing the architecture.

I also found where Bogost talks about visual rhetoric extrodinarily interesting-- possibly because architecture could fall into this realm of rhetoric or possibly because I think that globalization has become what it is because of the fact that at a click of button (via the World Wide Web) you can be seeing, learning, experiencing, etc, just about anything from anywhere in the world all through visual experiences coming from your computer monitor/screen. Bogost talks about how "Helmers and Hill agrue that visual rhetoric is particularlly essential in the face of globalization and mass media. Visual images on television, clothing, retail storefronts, and public spaces are nearly ubiquitous, offering a strong incentive to understand the rhetoric of such media." (pg. 21) We know that it has been proven that the images on perfect, beautiful girls on the covers of magazines have negative impacts on young girls self-esteem and leading to feelings that they need to look like that. That, to me, seems only logical that it would be considered rhetoric because of its persuasive nature and and communication of what beauty should be.

Tuesday, September 2, 2008

To Mii or not to Mii....

So I was playing Wii this weekend with my family while I was home for their long vacation... While home, we were playing Wii and as I was helping create new Mii's for the friends that had come over for the evening, I thought about how these Mii's.... here I was creating a Mii that looked very similar to our friends. It is limited in exactly how much you can make these little Mii's look like you, but how different is that to how an avatar or some other sort of electronic person in some other game such as Second Life or others? Is the Mii an image of us? an electronic version of us? So after playing Wii bowling and other such games, they wanted to try Wii Fit. For those who have never played Wii Fit, the game uses a balance board for different activities, but also weighs you. It then makes your Mii fatter or skinner based on your weight. At that point, the Mii really does become a likeness of each of us....

The game seemed so normal to me before this class.... it seems now new possibilities and ideas concerning the games I play are new....

Tuesday, August 26, 2008

Week 1 Discussion question

This weeks reading was interesting and forced me to think about play in a new way. My questions line in the area of question because of confusion as well as in question in the realm of exploration.

My first question has to do with the voluntary nature of play. On page 7 of the article, it says "first and foremost... all play is a voluntary activity." Does that remain true when a voluntary activity such as gambling becomes a addiction? Once play as a voluntary activity has become an addiction where the player loses control of what he/she does, is it still voluntary?

My second question is one related to the function of play in culture. If play is a function of culture proper, how does that change from one culture to the next in some way possibly like the ways our languages, ideals, etc changes from one culture to the next? Do we as adults subconsciously ingrain our culture and cultural ideals into our children through their play and the ways we guide them in the play? (This sort of stemmed out of a thought trail about children, especially little girls, playing "house". In many cases, the little girls want to be the mommy who takes care of the baby all day long while the daddy is gone to work.-- This seems to reinforce the conservative culture where the man of the family is the bacon winner while the woman is the child bearer and rearer and the one who stays home to clean and cook)

My third question is sort of related to my second one-- Social manifestation/relation of play to culture on Page 7. Since birth we are ingrained in culture through play. How is play in primitive play of infants and young animals (children in this specific case) not considered a higher form of play even if it is clearly shaping, affecting, and being affected by culture?

Finally, as an architect and one who thinks about all things in the function and aesthetic, my next question is based in play and the aesthetic. Announcers and broadcasters regularly use the term "beautiful" to describe plays in sporting events that are neither graceful, rhythmic, or harmonic, but are described as beautiful. (Ex.-- hail mary pass, last minute wining touch down) How does this fall into this idea of play as the article discusses?